Understanding Dual Agency: Can One Real Estate Agent Represent Both Buyer and Seller?

Photo by Jakub Å»erdzicki on Unsplash

Introduction: What Is Dual Agency in Real Estate?

In real estate, the term dual agency refers to a situation where a single real estate agent, or brokerage, represents both the buyer and the seller in the same transaction. This arrangement is legal in many states, but is subject to strict regulations and, in some areas, is outright prohibited. Understanding how dual agency works, its potential benefits and drawbacks, and the laws governing it in your state is critical for anyone considering buying or selling property.

How Dual Agency Works and Where It’s Legal

Dual agency occurs when a real estate agent or brokerage enters into a legal agreement to represent both the buyer and the seller in a transaction. This agent is required to remain neutral, providing equal treatment to both parties and refraining from advocating for one side over the other. While this can streamline communication and the negotiation process, dual agency is not legal everywhere. As of April 2023, dual agency is illegal in at least eight states , including Alaska, Colorado, Florida, Kansas, Maryland, Oklahoma, Texas, and Vermont [1] . In states where it is allowed, written consent from both the buyer and seller is typically required before proceeding [4] .

Key Benefits and Potential Risks of Dual Agency

There are several reasons why buyers and sellers might consider dual agency:

Convenience : Working with a single agent can make scheduling showings, communicating, and negotiating simpler and faster.
Potential for Smoother Transactions : Dual agency has the potential to streamline paperwork and reduce delays, as all parties communicate through one professional [4] .

However, dual agency also introduces significant challenges:

Conflict of Interest : The agent cannot fully advocate for one party’s best interests without potentially disadvantaging the other. This may result in both sides feeling underrepresented or uncertain whether their confidential information is protected [1] .
Limited Advocacy : Negotiating price reductions, repair credits, or other concessions can become problematic, as the agent must remain neutral and cannot give strategic advice to either party [1] .
Legal and Ethical Risks : If an agent fails to maintain neutrality or mishandles confidential information, this can result in legal disputes or disciplinary action from licensing boards. Lawsuits are not uncommon when one party feels disadvantaged by the arrangement [1] .

State-Specific Regulations: When Is Dual Agency Allowed?

Dual agency is regulated at the state level and is illegal in several states . For example, in Texas , the Texas Real Estate Commission (TREC) strictly prohibits dual agency . Agents must choose to represent either the buyer or the seller, or else act as an
intermediary
-a neutral facilitator who cannot advocate for either side or share confidential information [2] , [3] . In these cases, buyers and sellers should expect to have their own separate representation or agree to work with an intermediary broker who simply manages the process without offering direct advice or guidance.

In states where dual agency is legal, it is almost always required that both parties give informed, written consent before the arrangement can proceed [1] . Agents are obligated to fully disclose the potential conflicts and limitations of dual agency, and clients must understand what they are agreeing to before signing any agreements.

How Buyers and Sellers Can Navigate Dual Agency

If you are considering entering a real estate transaction where dual agency is an option, there are several steps you can take to protect your interests:

Research State Laws : Begin by determining whether dual agency is permitted in your state. If uncertain, contact your state real estate commission or search for official agency guidelines online. For example, the Texas Real Estate Commission (TREC) provides detailed information about agency relationships and prohibited practices.
Ask for Full Disclosure : Before agreeing to dual agency, request that your agent provide a written disclosure outlining their responsibilities, the limitations of their role, and how confidential information will be handled. This is not only best practice-it is often required by law [4] .
Consider Independent Representation : If you are concerned about potential conflicts or want full advocacy, you may choose to hire your own agent. This is especially important if you are negotiating on key terms, such as price or repairs, and want to ensure your interests are vigorously defended.
Consult Legal or Real Estate Professionals : If you have questions or concerns about agency relationships, consider consulting a real estate attorney, or contact your local real estate board for guidance.

For those in states where dual agency is prohibited, your agent should immediately disclose any situation where an accidental dual agency might arise, and either step back to represent only one party or act solely as a neutral intermediary, as required by law [2] .

Real-World Example: Dual Agency in Action

Imagine a buyer is interested in a property listed by the same agent they have been working with to find a home. In states that allow dual agency, both parties must be informed and agree in writing that the agent will represent both sides. The agent then cannot advise the buyer on how low to offer, nor can they tell the seller whether to accept an offer below asking price. Instead, the agent facilitates the transfer of information and documentation, but strategic negotiation advice is off the table. In practice, both parties might feel they do not receive the full benefit of advocacy from the agent, leading some consumers and industry professionals to be wary of the arrangement [1] .

In Texas, by contrast, if such a situation arises, the brokerage must act as an intermediary, and the agent may not provide direct negotiation advice to either party. This system is designed to protect consumers and avoid the conflicts inherent in dual agency [3] .

Step-by-Step Guidance for Buyers and Sellers

If you are entering a real estate transaction and want to ensure your interests are protected, follow these steps:

Determine Your State’s Law: To find out whether dual agency is permitted in your state, visit your state’s real estate commission website or search for “[Your State] real estate dual agency laws.” Official sites usually end in .gov or .us.
Request Written Disclosures: Insist on all agency relationships and disclosures being provided in writing. Read these carefully and ask questions if anything is unclear.
Seek Independent Advice: Even if dual agency is permitted, consider having your own agent or an attorney review documents and negotiations to avoid conflicts of interest.
Understand the Limits: Remember that in a dual agency or intermediary situation, the agent’s ability to negotiate or offer confidential advice is limited by law. Make sure you are comfortable with this arrangement before proceeding.
Communicate Openly: If you have concerns, raise them with your agent or brokerage immediately. Regulations require agents to be transparent about their roles and any changes in representation.

Potential Challenges and How to Address Them

Dual agency can present several challenges, including:

Feeling Underrepresented: Both parties may feel their interests are not fully protected, especially during tough negotiations.
Legal Risks: If the agent fails to properly disclose the arrangement or breaches confidentiality, lawsuits and disciplinary action may follow.
Complex Transactions: Complicated sales involving contingencies, repairs, or unusual terms may be harder to manage in a dual agency or intermediary scenario.

To address these challenges, always prioritize open communication, transparency, and independent legal or real estate advice as needed. If you feel uncomfortable or unsure at any stage, you can request to be released from a dual agency agreement or seek alternate representation.

Alternatives to Dual Agency

If dual agency is prohibited or not desirable, consider these alternatives:

Single Agency: Each party has their own agent, ensuring dedicated advocacy and guidance throughout the transaction.
Transaction Broker or Intermediary: In some states, a broker can act as a neutral facilitator, managing paperwork and logistics without offering direct advice to either side.
Team Approach: Some brokerages assign different agents within the same office to represent the buyer and seller separately, avoiding conflicts of interest.

Key Takeaways

Whether dual agency is right for you depends on your state’s laws, your comfort level, and the complexity of your transaction. Always seek full disclosure, understand your rights, and consider independent representation when in doubt. Real estate professionals are required to act ethically and transparently; never hesitate to ask questions or seek outside advice before signing any agreement.